Lee Sharpe highlights some of the opportunities and possible pitfalls in investing in property – even residential property – via a pension scheme.
This article looks at the tax implications of putting property into a pension fund, and focuses in particular on recent developments in relation to ordinary residential buy-to-let (BTL) property. It should be emphasised that this is a potentially very complex area and professional advice should always be sought before investment decisions are made.
Property and pensions
It is very common for pension funds to want to hold investments in property, perhaps because of their perceived reliability. Aside from portfolio diversity in ‘ordinary’ pension funds, it is quite common for people to invest directly into property as part of their retirement planning (‘my properties are my pension’).
It is possible to invest in specific properties within an approved pension scheme, with all of the normal tax breaks that go with scheme approval, although direct investment in BTL properties is prohibited. This is unfortunate: A recent ‘This is Money’ article reported that, on average, BTL property has increased in value by around 1,400% from 1996 to 2014 – beating the returns on practically all other comparable investments. Of course, not all residential properties have made such outstanding returns. If they had, this article might perhaps have been written in the Caymans, rather than in Manchester!
Tax breaks for investing in property via pensions
Using an appropriate pension scheme, the investor can:
Limitations and pitfalls from a property perspective
Properties can be cumbersome because each parcel tends to have so much value. While it is possible to work with contributions of part-interests, it can be time-consuming and legally expensive to arrange.
If transferring property ‘in-specie’, there is likely still to be a CGT charge on any uplift in value on disposal, even if no money changes hands.
There may be VAT and stamp duty land tax implications for a ‘transfer in’ of property – for instance, with a commercial property, it may be preferable for the pension scheme to register for VAT and to ‘opt to tax’ the property.
Although you can contribute up to £3,600 a year into a pension in any case, you generally need ‘relevant earnings’ (generally, earnings from employment or self-employment) in order to make larger contributions. Rental income alone does not count as relevant earnings. Note, however, that an employer contribution (such as from one’s own company) is not bound by relevant earnings.
Even if you have sufficient relevant earnings, (or an employer contribution), there is an ‘annual allowance’ which limits how much you can put into a pension and still enjoy all tax reliefs. It is currently £40,000 per annum, although unused allowance may be ‘rolled up’, for up to three years, giving four in total. However, this may still represent only a small part of the value of some properties, which is why part-transfers may still be useful. Each individual has his or her own annual allowance, so joint ownership can make even large property transfers viable.
Residential buy-to-let investment via a pension
While a pension scheme may not hold a BTL property as a direct investment, some relatively recent investment funds have opened which concentrate only on BTL properties, in the form of a real estate investment trust (REIT). REITs are property-oriented funds with shares which are traded on the London Stock Exchange, and which do not normally pay tax on rental income or capital gains on property sales.
If held in a pension scheme, this would mean that income from the BTL REIT holding would be free of income tax, and the sale of the holding would be free of CGT as well. It should also be practically much easier to match the amount of a desired pension investment to a corresponding number of REIT shares, than to a specific property in a directly held portfolio.
Holding a BTL REIT instead of investing in property directly would therefore seem to include the potential to access the excellent investment returns afforded by BTLs, even through a pension wrapper, although holding a publicly-traded investment would clearly mean handing over direct control over the quality and management of the fund’s housing stock (‘investments can go down as well as up’).
What about existing buy-to-let property?
Of course, if you already hold a BTL portfolio, selling up and converting it into a REIT holding may be expensive from a CGT perspective!
However, one of the more interesting points about a particular BTL REIT I have seen is that I understand they are offering to swap their REIT shares directly for shares in companies which hold suitable BTL property stock – in other words, if you hold your residential properties in a company, then you could swap shares in your company for shares in the REIT. This transaction would be tax-neutral, in that a share-for-share exchange would normally postpone any CGT until the new shares were actually sold, or (say) transferred to your pension – it might well be easier then to manage contributions in stages and/or with joint holders and make use of several years’ worth of annual exemptions over time.
Practical Tip :
Pensions can be far more accommodating than many investors realise, and can offer significant opportunities for expanding a property business – through tax efficiencies or, in some cases, additional financing.
While it is possible to ‘put’ existing property (or part-interests in existing property) into a pension, care is needed to avoid the traps. As we have seen, it is now possible for a pension to acquire residential property via a share-type holding, potentially to access what has historically proven to be some of the best returns available.
The rules for pensions are changing and in many ways for the better, as they become more flexible. The market for pension products is still responding to changes in legislation. As pensions’ new flexibility offers more choice, competent professional advice is even more important to ensure that investors make the very best of what is on offer.
This is a sample article from the monthly Property Tax Insider magazine. Go here to get your first free issue of Property Tax Insider.