Must the value of our properties be added together for stamp duty purposes?

View All Questions View Questions From:

Must the value of our properties be added together for stamp duty purposes?

Question

My mother is selling her house to her grandson for £138000 and her grandson is selling his house to my mother for the same amount.  They have been independently valued at these amounts for mortgage purposes.

 

We have been informed by our solicitor that because they are related the value of both properties must be added together for stamp duty purposes which puts them into the 3 percent bracket. 

 

Both houses are in a disadvantaged area so if valued at £138000 no stamp duty would be payable, but as they are being added together not only does it put the payment up but also means we can't claim the money back as it's a disadvantaged area.

 

Can you tell me if this is factually correct and if there is any way to not have to pay this duty which seems slightly crazy bearing in mind that if they were strangers they wouldn't have to pay it.  It seems that they are being penalised for being related.

 

Arthur Says

As your question stands, unfair as it may seem, the solicitor is correct.

 

However, if, instead of doing the exchange, the first side physically paid £138,000 to the second side, and acquired the second house, and then when the dust had settled on the first transaction, the second side physically paid £138,000 to the first side and acquired the first house, as an independent transaction, then maybe the Revenue would accept that there should be no Stamp Duty to pay.

About Arthur Weller

Over 350 consultations successfully completed by Arthur though this site!
Arthur Weller is a Chartered Tax Advisor (CTA) and an integral part of the Property Tax Portal team. He offers a special rate tax advisory service on any aspect of UK taxation, including property taxation, for as little as £97 for a 30 minute telephone tax consultation.

Key Facts:

- Over 90% of queries are answered within 30 minutes and within 3 days!
- Over 300 consultations done by Arthur through this website!
- You pay for the advice after it has been given

Here is what one of our customers had to say:

“Arthur contacted me the next day.  He phoned promptly and offered me clear and concise advice which he referenced to the HMRC website, taking me through section by section and explaining the implications each step of the way. 

He also sent me an MP3 recording of the session so that I was able to absorb the information more fully.  I am extremely impressed by his professionalism. Money very well invested as his advice will save me thousands of pounds.  I wholeheartedly recommend his services.

Thank you very much.” V. Loughery


To learn more about this service click here.

Ask a Question